|If you look closely, you can see that the fence is at fetlock height…an indication of the depth of the snow.|
Coincidentally or possibly not, I found myself working on two little training projects that didn't require the clicker, and one didn't even require treats. One was dealing with horses crowding at the gate to come in and the other was Percy's general attitude about people in his space.
While I love having multiple horses out together to be social here (at our previous farm they were more separated due to space limitations), it has meant that everybody wants to come in at once. Having very friendly youngsters and not wanting to use pressure to back others off, I considered working on teaching them to "station" in different places (standing at a specific target away from me) but a) that meant spending time preparing that training and it was too cold for that and b) I have trouble with stations when anything put on the ground just gets covered with snow and electric fence doesn't really have rugged enough posts to hang targets on.
Instead, I did the following. Entering the paddock, I put a halter on the horse or pony closest to the gate, and then asked the next in line to back up a step (a known behavior for all). I gave a tongue click and dropped a handful of hay stretcher pellets on the ground to keep him busy and back while I scooted the first horse through the gate and shut it behind us. Then I would repeat with the next horse, and so on. This quickly developed into a routine which the horses anticipated. While I was putting the halter on the closest one, the next one would voluntarily back up and wait for me to come and drop treats at his feet (nothing like fresh snow, frozen hard every day to have a nice clean place to drop treats on the ground). Since that is now being offered, I should probably put it on cue somehow…maybe a "wait" cue which Percy knows but the others don't. In any case, it has made bringing horses in quite pleasant and calm.
The other issue was that Percy was getting quite cranky with people entering his stall. I think partly it was the cold- everybody was cranky. Another part was that he didn't like people moving quickly. Lastly- this is the first winter he's been locked in a stall. Previously he could get in a stall but was not locked in, so he may have been feeling somewhat trapped and defensive. And of course, he likes to be working all the time. He got angry when someone just went in his stall to fill a water bucket and didn't ask him to do something that he could earn treats for.
I decided to initiate a new little ritual which did not involve any clicks or food. I've done bits in the past of explaining to him that there won't always be treats when I show up, but this was a new situation and I wanted to be methodical about it. If I approached his stall and his ears went back, I'd stop until the ears came up again. I know him well enough to know that he didn't want me to leave- he just wanted to know what was going on. But I also didn't want ear pinning to become the norm. I needed a consistent approach that he could rely on. Once his ears were relaxed again (usually pricked up to see me), I opened his stall door, which he knows as a cue to back up so he did. Rather than click and treat that, I just reached out to rub his face gently. Sometimes that irritated him so I'd freeze again until the ears relaxed. At first I'd just barely graze his face and then proceed to fill his water bucket or pick his stall. Any time he got cranky, I would stop all movement again until he relaxed.
This has evolved into a new nighttime routine. I approach his stall, he backs to let me in and then when I approach, he buries his head in my chest while I rub his face, play with his ears and stroke the sides of his neck. He loves to lick the front of my coat while I do this…that could get soggy when I'm only wearing one layer of clothing this summer.
While I did not use formal "clicker training" for these little projects, my knowledge of the rules of Operant Conditioning, as well as observation skills, did allow me to be successful.
- Animals will repeat what is reinforced.
- Use reinforcers the animal chooses
- Break the training down into manageable pieces so the animal can be successful
- Observe the emotions carefully
The crankiness is a little harder to parse. While there was no food reinforcer, there was the reinforcer of attention. I had to know Percy to know that was reinforcing to him. There was a bit of Negative Punishment going on as well as Positive Reinforcement. (my cheat sheet for those definitions are think math for Positive and Negative- one takes something away, one adds something. Reinforcement makes something more likely to happen again, while punishment makes it less likely). So when I froze my movements when his ears went back, I was removing something- the attention- to make it less likely he pinned them in the future- punishment. When his ears came up again, I continued my approach, adding the attention (positive) to make it more likely he'd keep his ears up in the future (reinforcement).
I certainly could have clicked and reinforced him for ears up on my approach…but that would have required removing my mitten to dig out treats. Brr!
It was above 40 today and I have just returned from Clicker Expo- more stories to come.